How Can Real Estate Agents Avoid Being Sued for Misrepresentation?

In the real estate industry, a real estate agent's core responsibility is to provide accurate property information. If an agent provides inaccurate or misleading information, it may constitute real estate agent “misrepresentation”, which could lead to legal liability and even compensation for buyers' or tenants' losses. Understanding the risks of misrepresentation and how to avoid these pitfalls is crucial for real estate agents.

Content Summary

1. What is Real Estate Agent Misrepresentation?
2. Real Case: Concealing Information about a Stigmatised Property
3. Legal Liability of Real Estate Agents
4. How to Avoid Misrepresentation?
5. Conclusion

Real estate agent misrepresentation refers to intentionally or unintentionally providing inaccurate or misleading property information in advertisements or conversations with clients, leading buyers or tenants to make incorrect decisions. For example, if an agent claims a property includes a parking space when it does not, such misleading information could result in financial loss for the buyer and potentially lead to a compensation lawsuit.

The three key conditions that constitute real estate agent misrepresentation include:

1. Statement of Fact: The agent made a factual description related to the property.
2. False Statement: The statement is untrue or misleading.
3. Influencing Decision: The false statement misled the victim, who consequently entered into a contract.

It is important to note the distinction between a statement of fact and a statement of opinion. For example, if an agent says, “The room should fit a bed and a piano,” it is an opinion. However, if they say, “The room area is 150 square feet,” this is a statement of fact. If the actual area is found to be only 100 square feet, the agent would be legally liable for this misrepresentation.

According to a Consumer Council case, a buyer asked an agent if a second-hand unit had any “unusual” incidents and received a “no” answer. However, after signing the contract, the buyer discovered that a fall incident had occurred in the unit, ultimately deciding to terminate the transaction and reclaim the deposit. The court ruled that the agent failed to conduct reasonable inquiries and was liable to compensate the buyer for their losses.

According to Hong Kong's Estate Agents Practice (General Duties and Hong Kong Residential Properties) Regulation, agents must ensure that the property information provided is accurate. If an agent provides misrepresentation, they may face fines, compensation, or even licence suspension. Buyers have the right to claim losses under the Misrepresentation Ordinance, including forfeited deposits or the difference between the purchase price and actual market value, and in some cases, may choose to rescind the transaction.

When an owner entrusts a real estate agent to sell a second-hand property, the real estate agent must enter into an agreement with the owner using a prescribed form, commonly known as a “listing agreement”, which specifies the responsibilities between the real estate agent and the seller. If the real estate agent makes a misrepresentation, whether the owner is liable depends on the facts of the case.

1. Verify Property Information:Agents should carefully verify property details, including area, property age, parking spaces, and facilities, and provide all necessary documents to ensure clients fully understand the property's condition.
2. Written Confirmation Record:After every important communication with a client, details should be confirmed in writing to avoid future disputes arising from unclear verbal communication.
3. Transparent Communication:Maintain clear communication with clients, promptly verify and explain uncertain information, and reduce the risk of misleading.
4. Remind of Potential Risks:Remind clients that offers or rebates may affect bank mortgage approval, helping them understand the associated risks.
5. Adhere to Scope of Duties:Agents should ensure that the advice they provide is within their professional scope, avoiding overstepping to give opinions beyond their professional scope.

As a real estate agent, it is essential to always maintain professionalism and caution, ensuring that property information provided is accurate. Through data verification, written confirmation, and transparent communication, agents can reduce the legal risks of misrepresentation, ensuring clients receive due protection in property transactions.

Please fill in the form below. We will contact you as soon as we receive your message.